Monsters of Ohio Review

Monsters of Ohio by John Scalzi, featuring illustrated monsters and the A Fixed Moment review graphic.
Books / Review

John Scalzi combines monsters, corporate greed, and social commentary in an entertaining but uneven story.

I’m a fan of John Scalzi’s work, particularly The Kaiju Preservation Society, which I found genuinely funny and entertaining. So I went into Monsters of Ohio expecting another clever story filled with his usual humor and social commentary.

What I got was an enjoyable but uneven book with some interesting ideas that didn’t always come together.

Cover of Monsters of Ohio by John Scalzi
Cover art by Michael Koelsch. Image courtesy of Tor Books.
Book Details

Title: Monsters of Ohio

Author: John Scalzi

Publisher: Tor Books / Macmillan

Publication: November 3, 2026

ISBN: 9780765389039

Visit the official book page

Monsters, Money, and Small-Town Problems

Set in the fictional town of Richland, Ohio, the story follows Mike Boyd, who returns home after decades away. The town is struggling economically, its largest employer is closing, and things are about to get considerably stranger.

Monsters enter the picture, along with corporate greed, corruption, and increasingly bizarre situations.

Scalzi does a good job using an absurd premise to explore familiar problems, particularly how corporate interests can exploit struggling communities. The characters are entertaining, the humor works, and there’s some worthwhile social commentary beneath all the weirdness.

But one aspect of the story kept pulling me out of it.

When the Extraordinary Becomes Ordinary

My biggest issue was how quickly people seemed to accept the existence of actual monsters.

There are moments of genuine shock, but before long, characters appear remarkably comfortable carrying on with their lives. We’re talking about creatures and events that should completely change someone’s understanding of reality, yet the reactions often feel surprisingly casual.

Initially, I found this difficult to believe. But the more I thought about it, the more I wondered whether that was intentional.

We live in a world where we’re constantly exposed to horrific events. School shootings, wars in Gaza and Ukraine, troubling reports of immigration enforcement, and countless other tragedies dominate the news. We react with horror or outrage, discuss them, and then move on to the next headline.

Not necessarily because we don’t care, but because there’s always another crisis demanding our attention.

Something once unimaginable becomes another event we’ve learned to live alongside.

Could Scalzi be making a point about how easily we’ve become desensitized to the extraordinary?

It’s an interesting possibility, especially given the book’s other social commentary. I don’t know whether that was his intention, but it made me reconsider one of my biggest criticisms.

Even so, the characters’ reactions still felt too casual at times, and I had trouble fully believing in the world Scalzi created.

The Verdict

Worth a Moment of Your Time?

Monsters of Ohio isn’t a bad book. It has entertaining characters, some genuinely funny moments, and ideas worth thinking about.

But the underlying commentary sometimes interested me more than the story itself.

Perhaps my expectations were higher because I’ve enjoyed Scalzi’s previous work. The Kaiju Preservation Society showed how well he can combine an absurd premise with humor and an engaging story. This one has some of those ingredients, but the result wasn’t nearly as satisfying.

Would I reread it? Probably not. Would I recommend it? Not particularly, although fans of Scalzi’s humor and lighter monster fiction may enjoy it more than I did.

Ultimately, it’s an okay book with some good moments and interesting ideas. Some of those ideas stayed with me longer than the story itself.

And while this one didn’t quite land for me, I’m still a fan of Scalzi’s work and look forward to what he writes next.

Author John Scalzi
John Scalzi

Author of Monsters of Ohio, The Kaiju Preservation Society, and Starter Villain.

Author photograph credited to John Scalzi. Image provided by Tor Books.

Editorial disclosure: Tor Books provided official promotional materials for this review. All opinions expressed are independent.